PDA

View Full Version : Predictions: OnLive = Vaporware



Vaporware
03-25-2009, 08:12 PM
I have some srs problems with this so called touted online delivery service.

#1, remember the Phantom Gaming System? yeah. Same sort of hype marketing scheme that gave zero technical details in order to run a pump + dump securities fraud.

#2, 720p streaming = 2GB/hr in bandwidth. You will cap out your monthly connection in 20-27hrs with most N. American ISPs.

#3, LAG. There's just no way this can work without a minimum 10mbp/s connection, and even then too expensive. Maybe this would work in Japan where a 100mbit connection is only $20 a month w/no cap, but I'm skeptical of their GPU servers being able to handle a full load of CRYSIS gamers. The CEO also claimed he 'went into hundreds of homes to test for lag and solved the problem' in the press conference without of course giving details.

#4, Only 1 player per internet connection can play lest you go over your cap in just 10hrs, or lag out as compared to console games where multiple players can play online at the same time.

#5, uptime. what happens if the server goes down? you can't even play your games offline. surely it will be easy to inject packets back to the server to lag out the game to your benefit or launch a DDoS attack on them.

#6, Everything the CEO of OnLive has touched has ended up being sold to MicroSoft. I am skeptical this is either an April Fools Day joke, or some sort of M$ viral marketing where they'll end up buying the totally unknown compression technology and burying it.

#7, Onlive ROOTKITS to run the browser software = dangerous.

that is all :)

VaporGuar
03-25-2009, 08:19 PM
Onlive is just a big, big piece of garbage that is inviable right now.
enjoy your lag and server errors and server maintentance, Onlive "players"
Onlive will never work.

spyroth
03-25-2009, 11:38 PM
Onlive is just a big, big piece of garbage that is inviable right now.
enjoy your lag and server errors and server maintentance, Onlive "players"
Onlive will never work.

Don't say that before you even tried it. What wrong with all you people, before you bash anything give it a try.

gronfors
03-26-2009, 01:54 AM
Once again, people can't believe something extraordinary new and out of the ordinary
but let's go through each point for fun

#1, They have shown the service working perfectly, and they have given out technical specifications (to a small extent)

#2, I would assume they are doing it in a way that Isn't going to "cap" your monthly connection.... and since when does that exist? (at least I'm SURE I would have gone over any cap by now)

#3, See opening statement

#4, How many people have multiple Game Systems playing at once...?

#5, If it goes down, you find a life for a few hours... and find something else to do with your life

#6, Who cares if it gets sold? If Microsoft buys it, then they see it could be revolutionary, and I'm sure they would use it, probably just as well...

#7, Didn't know that they had Rootkits

gronfors
03-26-2009, 01:58 AM
ah, read this:

http://onlivefans.com/showthread.php?t=47

Makes a lot more sense than me